Morrissey Central "HOLD ON, I’M CARMEN" (January 1, 2025)

Carmen Vandenberg working very hard at rehearsals for the New Year's Eve show at the Hollywood Palladium.
Photographs by Rudolpho.
82c6c71f0e676e9a83c6f0373dee62acbd853018.jpg
3230d24bc520bea99bc1293ff24afb7dc81a9e0e.jpg
afce7da4e656c0b7b9e688ca7019361e67a9c62d.jpg
1df0c397612860851cbd8ce9b2295b0434cf4b58.jpg

 
That I agree on.

But in those days, at the peak of his career, in between classics like Viva Hate and Your Arsenal, it did feel a bit underwhelming.
I completely agree. However, it wasn't due to the musicianship on the record, rather the quality of the songs and the production.
It boils down to the usual conclusion: Morrissey has the right to pick whoever he wants to play with. The audience has the right to emphasize when he has sub-par musicians.
 
No, I mean quite the opposite. Morrissey should have real professional musicians who don't miss a beat, don't mess up songs and are able to play past solo and Smiths parts. Marr is a genius, but it's not that hard to play his part live. I just think, like I wrote, he has zero affinity in picking proper musicians.
Now that I think about it, the best and most decent musicians Morrissey had were all pre-Lads, as Street, Winstanley etc had access proper studio musicians from the UK.
No doubt musically Viva Hate is brilliant... but could he have toured with those musicians? Wasn't that the problem? He needed a band he could take on the road and eventually found the Lads. While a bit rough in the beginning they did vastly improve. He has yet to improve on Alain and Boz.
 
Last edited:
I remember that thread and it's over 20 years ago now :crazy:. This was regarding his playing live. Which I believe he didn't do after 2004 (until again in 2022 I believe). However, his songs still appeared on ROTT and YOR. So was he still considered 'part of the band' just not playing live? Was there ever any reason given why he appears on YOR but not on WPINOYB? I know this has all been covered before but I don't remember it.

Alain was still considered irreplaceable at the time. From Moz's True-To-You Q&A 2006...

"Q7: HOW HAS JESSE TOBIAS AFFECTED THE NEW ALBUM? Darragh, Dublin
-- hello Darragh
If you hear the new album you will notice a marked difference in sound, principally due to both Michael Farrell and to Jesse. Personally and musically, Jesse has made a big impact - You Have Killed Me, The Youngest Was The Most Loved, In The Future When All's Well, I Just Want To See The Boy Happy....these songs, especially, fully release the hounds. There are no Boz songs on this album, but strangely, it is the album on which Boz has been most involved and had such a massive input. Boz is 24-hour non-stop, and if impetus lulls, Boz steers everyone back on track.
If it seems to some people that Jesse has replaced Alain, I would like to say that this isn't true. There is no replacing and there is nothing but harmony amongst all the players. I understand that there are always poisonous assumptions on the SoLow site, but that's all just crap."
 
Never a good thing to be a ruggedly handsome woman.

Why? what happened? I assume you’re speaking from your own life experience as a ‘ruggedly handsome woman’.
 
Alain was still considered irreplaceable at the time. From Moz's True-To-You Q&A 2006...

"Q7: HOW HAS JESSE TOBIAS AFFECTED THE NEW ALBUM? Darragh, Dublin
-- hello Darragh
If you hear the new album you will notice a marked difference in sound, principally due to both Michael Farrell and to Jesse. Personally and musically, Jesse has made a big impact - You Have Killed Me, The Youngest Was The Most Loved, In The Future When All's Well, I Just Want To See The Boy Happy....these songs, especially, fully release the hounds. There are no Boz songs on this album, but strangely, it is the album on which Boz has been most involved and had such a massive input. Boz is 24-hour non-stop, and if impetus lulls, Boz steers everyone back on track.
If it seems to some people that Jesse has replaced Alain, I would like to say that this isn't true. There is no replacing and there is nothing but harmony amongst all the players. I understand that there are always poisonous assumptions on the SoLow site, but that's all just crap."
SoLow... love it.
 
“HOLD ON, NOT CARMEN” to anymore performances !!!!!!!!!!
Cause yer shite full stop.

Benny 🇬🇧 :knife:
 
I wish the title of this post had been, 'Hold on, I'll promise to learn guitar in the New Year.'
 
I guess the haters will see this as “a thinly veiled dig at her abilities” …or something.
I think it's not hate, it's that many of us don't accept it, we compare it, and many of us prefer Alain, I prefer him re,. No one knows her to talk about hate. And hating is something very strong and negative. Poor girl, I prefer Alain W.
It's not the band I want for Morrissey, I'm a relatively new fan and I consider Grosso what Moz did with Alain/Boz B.No I can't help but miss the people on stage
La mina no le hizo nada a nadie pero no se puede evitar la.comparacion con Alain !!Ademas destrozo Spring Heleed Jim!!Amo las canciones Alain Boz Moz simplemente los re banco a ellos .Me cuesta aceptarla no es la banda que yo quiero para Moz.
 

Trending Threads

Back
Top Bottom